Tom Sakic wrote:jurica wrote:Tom Sakic wrote:Long ago, the trinity was: Dylan, Cohen, Young
Today it is: Cohen, Cave, Waits (plus late "American" Johnny Cash

)
says who???
the late Johnny Cash can't get near MY top50, and Cave is somewhere down there as well (i'd say somewhere between 40 and 50). come on, you can LIKE Cave, but he doesn't realy play in the same league, when it comes to poetry, does he?
He does. He's much better than Waits in most moment, and actually, after Cohen & Dylan & Patti Smith is one of rarest with actual
poetry in his lyrics.
You cannot level your opinion to general degree, I mean, you mentioned Phil Ochs who has total lack of any relevance today. I only say that when I first time heard of Cohen, I got him in package of "greatest rock poets", and there was Dylan, Cohen, Neil Young and Joni Mitchell. Later, I discovered that most of
younger traders, collectors and fans prefer Cave, Cohen, Waits, and some of them Dylan. And Johnny Cash of American years was here also. And this opinions are spreaded thru most of today's musical & americana magazines. I personally have - as many others - Cash's American records in ten most favourites.
Tom,
just to set record straight. i did mention several times that on "my personal list" things would look the way they do. i even capitalized "MY" to make sure everybody would understand that. hell, that was what bothered me in your post in the first place - the fact that you DIDN'T say "my" trinity is...
you know very well why i reacted in the first place - you claim that Dylan is no longer as eminent as Cohen. and you claim that "most of
younger traders, collectors and fans prefer Cave, Cohen, Waits, and some of them Dylan" - "
some of them Dylan"
come on!!! i'm not a trader, and i'm not a collector, but
even i know that Dylan is the most traded of the bunch. i know that because whenever you write "Bob Dylan" into search engine hundreds of links pop up that are titled "Bob's boots" or "My Back Recordings"... the same happens if you use WinMX, DC++, torrents... you can find SOME Cohen, Cave and Waits, and SPADES of Dylan.
now, who's "leveling his opinion to general degree"?
and considering Cave's and Waits' poetry - i agree that Cave is MUCH better. i like Waits mostly for music, but also for lyrics his wife writes (the last few albums). but the fact is that i didn't place Waits in my trinity, so i don't see the point to this comparison.
i mentioned Ochs not as someone who is better than Cave, but as someone who is likely to be favored by Dylan fans as opposed to Cohen fans, which would be obvious if you quoted my whole post, and not just the part you chose.
the fact is that "greatest rock poets" can hardly be taken seriously. i mean -
Neil Young. that's another guy i like a lot but
a poet???
Shane,
nice to meet you. i think we (Croats) are probably the strongest "Cohen nation" in precentage of population
