Geoffrey wrote: ↑Fri Aug 02, 2024 12:33 am
...a girl once told me that i had misunderstood dylan's '
it ain't me, babe' song. she said that he was not rebuffing anyone, but was expressing his regret and disappointment that he was not the one she wanted. she said he wanted to be the one to open each and every door for her...
I think this may be an oversimplification of the song's meaning. I think that "he" is, in fact, actually rebuffing "her", directly telling her to go away, and "she" actually does want him, and is probably deeply in love with him. The problem is that he either cannot or will not be the
kind of person that she wants. As he perceives it, she wants a loving, devoted, committed partner who will be there for her at all times, and he simply does not see himself fulfilling that role in a relationship (whether by choice or by personality). She may not be aware of the fact that he cannot be, or does not want to be, the kind of man she wants, because of how much she loves him -- she hopes and maybe even believes that he is and will be the devoted and loving companion that she desires (love can be blind...).
He may certainly feel some regret at not being able to be the kind of man she wants -- he might wish that he could be that sort of man, but he realises that he is not. By pushing her away, he is probably believing that he is sparing her future disappointment, for if they did have a relationship, he would never be able to live up to her standards. That would be hard for her, being with someone who may not reciprocate her feelings with the same degree of devotion, and perhaps it would also be hard for him, for it would be a constant reminder of his shortcomings in a relationship, for he would always see the trouble in her eyes due to his not being able to love her the way she wants to be loved. Thus, in this case, he is assuming that she will be better off without him, free to find another man who will be able to be the kind of person she wants.
Or, maybe he simply has no interest in having a serious relationship, preferring to have the freedom to come and go as he pleases, with whomever he wants, doing whatever he wants, without any commitment or responsibility to another person, and thus, his rejection of her is a choice that he is making because he does not want to be the kind of person she wants, and he is not even willing to try.
So, is his "
it ain't me, Babe" declaration a callous shove-off by someone who just doesn't care, or is it a lament by someone who recognises his own shortcomings and wants to spare another person's feelings? Perhaps a bit of both: he may not know what he wants or who he is or how he wants to live, experiencing an internal struggle between a side of himself that wants to be the devoted lover, and a side of himself that wants no commitments, and being unable to reconcile these disparate elements of himself. Either way, "she" is going to be heartbroken, because the man she loves and wants to be with is not going to be with her, and she is not even being given a choice in the matter.
At least, that's my interpretation of the song, which may or may not be valid or accurate. Cheers!