I have no problem with people not liking the record. My issue is with people I've read throughout this thread suggesting that the critics who gave Dear Heather bad reviews didn't "get it" or whatever.
Also, not once did I suggest that the critics necessarily understand more about the album/Leonard Cohen/music than ordinary fans. Once again, I object to the view that critics know "nothing" or less than those fans who enjoyed the album. If you read back, you'll see that I argued as a critic I know "at least as much" about Cohen as his regular fans.
I think it's strange that some users of this board have categorized people who like or dislike the record by whether they understand it or not. There isn't anything to understand. You don't have to be an intellectual to enjoy Cohen, or
Dear Heather. I mean, come on - it isn't exactly
Ulysses.
Check
http://www.metacritic.com and search for
Dear Heather, you'll find that those of us who didn't like the record are very much in the minority. But that don't make it junk.
My review wasn't a prayer to Cohen, seen as I don't think I could ever like an artist
that much as to create a deity out of one. I don't necessarily want him to return to a specific era of his music and rehash it, I just feel that the standard has dropped considerably since
The Future (which in itself is a little patchy), and that I really want him to make one last, fantastic album. As one of the people who penned a comment on the bottom of my review said, "steal his Casio and shoot his backing singers". Personally, I'd probably let the singers stay, but the keyboard has to go. I challenge any of you to name another artist you would tolerate using such flimsy, tacky sounds to back such serious tones.
I liked what someone said earlier on about him recording an album in the style of Field Commander Cohen, that sounds cool. My favourite Cohen records are
The Songs Of...,
Death Of A Ladies' Man and
I'm Your Man - covering all of his many and varied eras. I think there's scope - even at seventy - for a huge Cohen album that comprises all of these sounds, and also includes (though not exclusively), him picking up the guitar once more. That'd be cool.