The Jakarta Post about Leonard

News about Leonard Cohen and his work, press, radio & TV programs etc.
User avatar
jarkko
Site Admin
Posts: 7338
Joined: Thu Jun 27, 2002 1:01 am
Location: Espoo, Finland
Contact:

The Jakarta Post about Leonard

Post by jarkko »

The Jakarta Post, Indonesia
http://www.thejakartapost.com/yesterday ... 060924.O02
Thanks to the author Cynthia Webb for the link & article!!
Cohen at 72: Still walking 'Boogie Street'
Features - September 24, 2006


So come, my friends, be not afraid. We are so lightly here. It is in love that we are made; In love we disappear. Tho' all the maps of blood and flesh Are posted on the door, There's no one who has told us yet What Boogie Street is for.

-- Boogie Street, Ten New Songs (Sony, 2001)

Cynthia Webb, Contributor, Gold Coast, Australia

The melancholy maestro, Canadian poet and songwriter Leonard Cohen, marked on Thursday 72 years of his life, which he has called "Boogie Street".

Cohen has been our musical companion since he released his first album in 1968, The Songs of Leonard Cohen, from which Suzanne was a huge hit. The music from this album was used on the soundtrack of the 1971 film Mr. and Mrs. Miller directed by a fan of his, Robert Altman.

For the youth of the Hippy era, his lyrics had a "trippy" feeling and suited the times during which so much was being questioned. And as one grew older and experienced more of life, the lyrics seemed to come into sharp focus in quite a painful way, because Cohen had an acute sense of the existential doubts that often plague us.

His words contained anguish, irony, sarcasm, despair, piercing truth and also recognition of beauty. Such is the nature of a poet.

Cohen is a Canadian Jew born in Montreal in 1934, and he began his career as a poet in the "beat" venues so typical during the 1950s of his youth. It is still hard to decide whether to call him a poet or a singer. Apparently, Cohen is grateful when people call him a singer, and feels he hardly qualifies for that description. He is just grateful that he has "been born with the gift of a golden voice", as he sings in Tower of Song.

Cohen credits his lifelong friend Judy Collins for encouraging him to become a singer -- she had recorded two of his songs on her 1966 album.

He had visited her with his guitar to sing for her and to ask her opinion about whether he could perform his own songs. Collins was impressed and later managed to get the nervous Cohen on stage at an anti-Vietnam War concert in 1967.

So he went ahead and recorded his first album, Suzanne (1968), and has been performing ever since. Blessed with a rich, resonant voice that sounds musical even if he wasn't actually singing.

Later, he realized that his mournful tone is complemented well by female voices singing harmony, and has consistently used this to beautiful effect.

Although he has written several novels and poetry volumes, he is best known around the world as a musician and songwriter, with 17 albums and compilations under his belt.

His most recent release was Dear Heather in 2004, which contains two tracks in response to the Sept. 11, 2001 attack on the World Trade Center and meditations about its causes and directions for the future.

"Some people said it's what we deserved, for sins against God, for crimes in the world. I wouldn't know, I'm just holding the fort, since that day they wounded New York," he sings. And "from bitter searching of the heart, we rise, to play a greater part".

In 1968 Cohen sang, "I told you when I came, I was a stranger," and he was so different it seemed true -- yet he was also the voice deep within us all.

In Stranger Song he sings of life: "You hate to watch another tired man lay down his cards, like he was giving up the holy game of poker. It's hard to hold the hand of anyone who's reaching for the sky just to surrender."

In several songs, he calls God, "The Dealer", as if this life experience might be nothing more than a game -- and us the gamblers with our hands full of randomly dealt cards that will decide our destiny.

Cohen has also sung about the "too hard stuff": the meaning of life, death, suicide, genocide, politics, hypocrisy, betrayal, sex, loss, self-doubt and the mystery of all this, coexisting with beauty, love, sweetness, hope and dreams.

Despair can be clearly heard in the song Dress Rehearsal Rag, in which a man is reminiscing, evaluating his life and considering suicide as he looks in the mirror while shaving.

Veering to the other extreme in a moment of epiphany, he sings: "I am not the one who loves, it's Love that chooses me. When Hatred with his package comes, you forbid delivery. So come my friend, be not afraid, we are so lightly here. It is in love that we are made, in love we disappear.

And then finding a middle road to cope with the great mystery, he continues: "The odds are there to beat. You win a while and then it's done, your little winning streak. And summoned now, to deal with your invincible defeat, you live your life, as if it's real, a thousand kisses deep."

Unforgettable words like this leave a mark on our heart, and over 40 years on, Leonard Cohen still has legions of devoted fans who have bought every one of his albums. Cohen has said out loud, with an often ironic or cynical voice, the things from which we have desperately tried to hide.

If It be Your Will, is a poignant prayer in memory of the Jews in Hitler's death camps. These lyrics could break your heart, like another song on this theme, Dance Me to the End of Love, which he considers one of his best works.

It refers to the doomed Jewish violinists who, knowing their own deaths were imminent, played beautiful music as other prisoners entered the death ovens: "Dance me to your beauty with a burning violin, dance me through the panic, `til I'm gathered safely in. Let me see your beauty when the witnesses are gone. Show me slowly what I only know the limits of, and dance me to the end of love."

Sometimes, Cohen appears to have lost hope for a better world, and this is heard in the lyrics of Everybody Knows: Everybody knows the boat is leaking/Everybody knows the Captain lied.

His songs have turned up regularly in various film and television show soundtracks, including Oliver Stone's anarchic 1994 film Natural Born Killers, for which The Future was like a black despairing anthem for a disintegrating world.

In Hallelujah, he reveals what comes close to being his credo: There is a crack in everything/that's how The Light gets in.

He has been quoted as saying, "It is the notion that there is no perfection -- that this is a broken world and we live with broken hearts and broken lives, but still, that is no alibi for anything. On the contrary you have to stand up and say 'hallelujah!' under those circumstances."

The final track on the same album, The Future, is his one and only instrumental offering, Tacoma Trailer. This is a work of incomparable beauty, an aural poem that restores our balance after all the despair in some of the other songs on the album.

A lifelong manic depressive, the evidence can be heard in his collected lyrics and poems as he explores every aspect of life between light and darkness.

From 1996 to 1999, Cohen lived at a Zen Buddhist center at Mount Baldy in California, where he is known by his Dharma name, Jikan, which means "the silent one".

Cohen first became interested in Zen in the 70s, yet he does not want to change his religion from Judaism.

At Mt. Baldy, he studied the most rigorous branch of Zen Buddhism, called Rinzai. He rose at 3 a.m. to cook for and take care of the old Zen Master, Joshu Sasak Roshi, at the time aged around 90. Special allowances were made for Cohen to be able to continue his work.

Cohen received The Order of Canada in 2003, the nation's highest civilian honor, and this year was inducted into the Canadian Songwriters Hall of Fame.

Like the work of Bob Dylan, whose career and world view parallel Cohen's in many ways, his songs have become classics during his lifetime. The legendary voice is deeper than ever and there is deep wisdom in his words.

In The Tower of Song he sings, " You'll be hearing from me baby, long after I'm gone." And while this is surely true, millions of Cohen fans are hoping that he won't be gone for a long time yet.
User avatar
lizzytysh
Posts: 25531
Joined: Thu Jun 27, 2002 8:57 pm
Location: Florida, U.S.A.

Post by lizzytysh »

. . . he was also the voice deep within us all . . . his songs have become classics during his lifetime. The legendary voice is deeper than ever and there is deep wisdom in his words.

Yes 8)

Cynthia gives a broad overview 8) , yet jumps around a lot and seems to have pretty much bypassed the latest, positive developments in Leonard's life... like his anxiety and manic-depression lifting; his collaboration with Anjani; and the greater sense of personal peace and acceptance in his songs. She also appears to have missed the sense of irony in Leonard's "golden voice" lyric :wink: .
If It be Your Will, is a poignant prayer in memory of the Jews in Hitler's death camps.
Is this true? I've never listened to it from that perspective.

Thanks for posting this, Jarkko.


~ Lizzy
Cynthia
Posts: 10
Joined: Tue Sep 26, 2006 3:00 am
Location: Gold Coast, Australia
Contact:

my recent article in the Jakarta Post, Indonesia

Post by Cynthia »

Notes on my article in The Jakarta Post (Sunday Edition, 24 Sept 06) :

Leonard is not very well known in Indonesia, and so the article is very general and meant as an introduction to the joys of his words and music for people who may not have heard of him at all, or may not have heard much of/any of his music. Also a tribute.

Among my friends and acquaintances in Indonesia, only one, who is older and went to University in the USA, had heard of him. It's another world there. They have their own Iwan Fals, a fantastic musician with an amazing career behind him, who perhaps could be thought of in the same 'genre', but his lyrics are not so deep. Political circumstances caused him to write a lot of protest songs and social comment, rather than personal journey lyrics.

The article is not quite in the original form I wrote it, after the paper's editors cut some paragraphs out and altered a few words. (Space restrictions apply in newspapers). According to my observations not many CDs by Leonard are available in Indonesia, but perhaps there might be greater demand this week, after the story. Let's hope so.

Interesting, the comment by Lisa, about "Dance me to the end of Love"...
I always saw the song that way, after seeing the Claude LeLouch movie, "Bolero"....1982, (sorry, don't know if it has an alternative French title) in which we actually see the violinists standing beside the queue of doomed Jews queuing to enter the death chambers. I read that this movie scene was based on fact. The more I listened to the song, the more sure I felt of that interpretation. And I got the same impression from "If it be your will" too actually.
Perhaps I am wrong, but it certainly fitted well.

Words of poetry and beauty often mean different things to different people, according to where and how we are in our life journey at the time. I have noticed that Leonard's words which I didn't really fully understand when I was in my 20s, can hit me with real power now, and I keep discovering things in them... or am I discovering things in me?Sometimes the words even seem to change meaning, or go deeper, after one has a new experience in life.

I wanted to say thank you to Leonard for enriching my life so much with his beautiful words and music and his fearless insights into the human condition. The thought of the man himself reading my humble tribute is a bit intimidating, and I hope he will forgive any inaccuracies, or things unmentioned (many) and accept my respect. -

Cynthia
Cynthia
Posts: 10
Joined: Tue Sep 26, 2006 3:00 am
Location: Gold Coast, Australia
Contact:

Post by Cynthia »

Sorry Lizzy - I called you Lisa by mistake in my posting. Apologies.
- Cynthia
User avatar
lizzytysh
Posts: 25531
Joined: Thu Jun 27, 2002 8:57 pm
Location: Florida, U.S.A.

Post by lizzytysh »

Hi Cynthia ~

No problem on calling me Lisa :D . I was wondering where 'her' comment had been and was already thinking that, perhaps, it had occurred elsewhere on the Forum and that you'd seen it there. My feeling [since first hearing the 'rumour' has been the same as yours on "Dance Me to the End of Love"] and suits me just fine to leave it that way... however, that has never precluded it as a love song of incredible depth, either, and so I view it that way, as well.

It's really great to actually get feedback from the author of an article/review, after posting comments on the article/review, itself. Thank you a lot for your elucidation of what you wrote and why. It all makes much greater sense, in light of what you've said. What I perceived as jumping around was probably much more cogent and flowing in its original form, as that editing process can really wreak havoc with what's originally submitted :( ... not to mention that what they might considerable most omittable might be what you consider least.

With Leonard being so more well known elsewhere in the world than he is in the U.S. [generally speaking, some geographical, urban pockets the exception], I presumed he was in Jakarta, as well. It reminds me of a line in one of Leonard's poems to the effect of these women [in India] not being interested in making love to him. Perhaps, it was only because they didn't know of him :wink: . I can see, with your explanation, where you were trying to assist in making people aware of him. It's an awesomely huge amount of ground to cover, given the different paths he's taken in various parts of the world throughout his life. Daunting. I credit you with doing a credible job in making people aware and, yes, hopefully they will seek more of him after reading your article 8) . He could certainly be of the measure of Iwan Fals, as [as you know] Leonard's lyrics can also be understood from the political protest/social comment, as well... and we ALL take our personal journeys, no matter where we live.

I'm going to listen to "If It Be Your Will" from your perspective, as I can imagine its being as you've interpreted it, and very profoundly so. Meanwhile, Cynthia, I can't tell you how gratifying it is to actually receive feedback, from the author, that puts my own comments into perspective. Thank you.

I'm certain that Leonard is/will be thrilled that you've cared and been moved enough to write your article, and will more than happily 'forgive' any 'inaccuracies,' as poetry/song really are in the heart of the beholder 8) .

~ Lizzy
Cynthia
Posts: 10
Joined: Tue Sep 26, 2006 3:00 am
Location: Gold Coast, Australia
Contact:

Post by Cynthia »

Thankyou so much too, for your comments Lizzy, and it's nice to 'meet' you. Wouldn't it be great to know from Leonard, about those two songs - whether he WAS thinking of the Jews in the camps, or something else. It's wonderful the way lyrics and poems and even prose, can be so 'relative' to the psychological condition, and to the experience of the receiver. Sometimes words fall upon our ears like revelations, and open things wide open - raise our spirit -other times if we are in pain about something, they will twist the knife. But it will only happen if the words come from someone like Leonard, words of insight and power.
However in the case of those two songs, I didn't have any personal connection to the Jewish experience, but they seemed to be telling that story, and of course, I knew Leonard is a Jew.
Just recently, "The Stranger Song" from the late 60s, struck me in a whole new way, after a personal experience involving the heart. Those words, "I told you when I came, I was a stranger", suddenly seemed like a warning which I had failed to fully comprehend when I should have.
And, in the Dear Heather albumn, I really 'feel' in my every cell, the experience being described in "Morning Glory" - something that happens just occasionally, when time stands still, and shimmers, and you are for an instant, at one with the universe, and I love the way he mutters to himself "Do you think you can pull it off?". It's just perfect. Even when we are "there" in perfection, we get doubts and fall out of it again. Human beings are so insecure.
And how about those words "I came so far for Beauty, I left so much behind". There came a time in my life, 10 years ago, when suddenly that was utterly real too, I did it myself and knew what it really meant.

That article was so hard to write, with the word number restriction, and knowing it needed to be very 'general'. Yet there is SO much more to say if the writing is for people already iniated into the world of Leonard Cohen,different things.
We know he is a unique man, an incredible talent and for me like a 'messenger' in my life... with me since "SUZANNE" came out. It's been like a dialogue- even though I've never met him, I feel a connection to him somehow. Probably all of have experienced it like this - Leonard our personal companion, talking to us about the things of life as we live it.
User avatar
lizzytysh
Posts: 25531
Joined: Thu Jun 27, 2002 8:57 pm
Location: Florida, U.S.A.

Post by lizzytysh »

Hi Cynthia ~

I don't have much time [very late for me] right now, so can't reply to you like I'd like to, so that'll have to wait. I just wanted to at least say something. I agree with what you've so beautifully said. Your last paragraph is absolutely right regarding that feeling of personal relationship so many of us have had with Leonard since first hearing [or at least listening to :wink: ] him. "Suzanne" was my first experience, too... and I've always identified with the lyrics. You're absolutely right, too, that writing for a 'Leonard audience' requires a whole different level of writing. I can only imagine how it had to have been for you to ratchet this article into existence. I remember someone once suggesting that I write a book on Leonard and I thought, "You've got to be kidding!?! [talk about feeling inadequate :shock: !]" Needless to say, I haven't written one... and can really appreciate how much you had to struggle to stick to a word limit, no less :shock: !
Leonard our personal companion, talking to us about the things of life as we live it.
Yes... that's exactly how it's felt. Further, as you've said, he's been a messenger. A desperately needed one, at times.

Okay, now I can sleep. Very nice to meet you, too, Cynthia :D .

~ Lizzy
User avatar
A'af
Posts: 76
Joined: Mon Aug 25, 2003 8:27 pm
Location: Jakarta, Indonesia

Post by A'af »

hey~ cyhintia...

Rite! LC is not well known in Indonesia, but I am is the only one in lawless crowd here..... adore to LC work...

Jakarta Post already cover LC a few past month ago, according to management problems...

gl chyinta...
thanks jarkko...
truth without a veil is uninteresting to human mind
Cynthia
Posts: 10
Joined: Tue Sep 26, 2006 3:00 am
Location: Gold Coast, Australia
Contact:

Post by Cynthia »

Salam kepada orang Indonesia. Dimana kamu tinggal? Apa artinya, "according to management problems?"
Berapa lama yang lalu, Jakarta Post mencetak artikel yang lain tentang Leonard Cohen? Artikel itu, oleh siapa? Apakah anda bisa kirim itu ke Forum? - dari Cynthia

(For the other's I have said: Hello, to the person from Indonesia. Where do you live? What do you mean "according to management problems?"
How long ago did Jakarta Post print the other article about LC? Who wrote it? Could you please send it to the Forum?)
User avatar
A'af
Posts: 76
Joined: Mon Aug 25, 2003 8:27 pm
Location: Jakarta, Indonesia

Post by A'af »

hai cynthia,
salam kenal dari jakarta....
beberapa waktu yang lalu "jakarta post" juga ada artikel mengenai LC, yaitu mengenai permasalahan, LC tertipu oleh manajernya terdahulu.
Nanti saya bisa siapkan, kalau memang perlu itu artikel?

PS: are you in Jakarta? dont hesitate to call me @ 08561199362
truth without a veil is uninteresting to human mind
User avatar
hydriot
Posts: 895
Joined: Sun May 21, 2006 3:07 am
Location: back in the UK

Post by hydriot »

Dance Me To The End Of Love is known to have been inspired by the violinists in the death camps, but not If It Be Your Will, which I have read is an adaptation of a traditional Jewish prayer. For me, If It Be Your Will is one of his finest songs, detailing the gentle joy of resignation (as in the Buddhist objective of abandonment of self) and nothing at all to do with the Holocaust.
“If you do have love it's a kind of wound, and if you don't have it it's worse.” - Leonard, July 1988
User avatar
lizzytysh
Posts: 25531
Joined: Thu Jun 27, 2002 8:57 pm
Location: Florida, U.S.A.

Post by lizzytysh »

Even though I had never heard of If It Be Your Will as having been inspired by or related to the Holocaust, there's certainly nothing that would prevent the adaptation of a traditional Jewish prayer for addressing the resignation/acceptance of those being murdered during the Holocaust. It is very interesting to read the lyrics from that perspective, with its having been such a literal silencing of their voices. It may not have brought about joy in them, but if even an acceptance of what some might have been apt to consider it as being 'God's will'... we sure feel differently about that notion, but if we were actually in that situation ourselves, that might be our only source of desperately-sought and peacefully-found comfort. I don't think it ever would have occurred to me to perceive this song in this way, but it sure does open one of those doors to try it. There were undoubtedly many traditional Jewish prayers being internally/externally spoken or quietly sung during those horrific times.

~ Lizzy
Last edited by lizzytysh on Wed Sep 27, 2006 11:16 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
hydriot
Posts: 895
Joined: Sun May 21, 2006 3:07 am
Location: back in the UK

Post by hydriot »

I suppose I come from a very different background. In 1940, as alone we faced invasion, Britons were told by Churchill to "take one with you". We assembled an absolutely vicious secret stay-behind army of 'auxiliaries' who had a life expectancy measured in days. That's the British way. I like to hope if I was ever about to be murdered I'd do my best to take at least one with me.

It is notable that the one great escape from a death camp, Sobivor, was organised by Soviet prisoners-of-war who happened to be mixed in with the civilians. I have never understood why it didn't happen elsewhere. So perhaps it is just training, or schooling, that determines how you react to your imminent murder.

Resignation in the face of terminal illness is one thing, and I can interpret If It Be Your Will in that context. But for me (and this may be a personal weakness rather than a strength) I cannot relate that song to the Holocaust at all.

"Do not go gentle into that good night.
Rage, rage against the dying of the light."
“If you do have love it's a kind of wound, and if you don't have it it's worse.” - Leonard, July 1988
User avatar
dick
Posts: 1185
Joined: Wed Sep 11, 2002 10:21 pm

Post by dick »

I'd like to add my thanks to you Cynthia, for a very good article and for sharing more of your thoughts here on the forum. It is a real treat and I like your insights, whether or not they express my views. Hope you post much more here.

I also hope you won't think I'm too picky, but two errors jumped out at me --- and I thought you would prefer to know just in case there is further use of the article.

First -- you comment on Dear Heather that two tracks have to do with 9/11. On That Day is clearly in direct response. Villanelle For Our Time , however, was in the works long before 2001. While the sentiments may be on target, the lyrics were written by F.R. Scott. Scott is described by Nadel as both a teacher of law and a poet at McGill when Leonard was there.

Second -- you state that "there is a crack..." is from the song Hallelujah,, while that marvelous line is actually from Anthem .

Again -- hope you aren't offended by my bringing these to your attention, and I look forward to reading much more from you.

Dick
User avatar
lizzytysh
Posts: 25531
Joined: Thu Jun 27, 2002 8:57 pm
Location: Florida, U.S.A.

Post by lizzytysh »

Hi Hydriot ~

I edited my post above to change horrendous to horrific.

You've introduced a very emotionally and psychologically complex issue that I'm not prepared to argue, debate, or even discuss [lack of time and lack of congealed information ~ one of my many unanticipated 'turnabouts' on this trip was that the two dvds I purchased at Birkenau are in PAL mode, so I've been unable to even watch them. The book I want to send for from the Jewish Museum in Berlin I've been unable to afford as yet. My computer guru here has 'transposed' the two dvds for me, so they supposedly will now play; however, they will not play on my own dvd ~ already tried. Next step is to clean the dvd player and if that doesn't work, buy a new one].

One of the things I learned when I visited Auschwitz-Birkenau in August, before the Berlin Event, was that one of the controls used at the concentration camps was that for every one prisoner who escaped, ten prisoners in their cell were executed. In the situation you've described, the predictable outcome of those who stayed behind may have been poor; however, at least they were armed. Not everyone in the camps had the advantage of being mixed in with civilians. They also were being starved, dehydrated, overworked to the point of exhaustion, and physically herded to the extent that having the physical ability or opportunity to manage an escape of any kind was all but humanly impossible. With 15 confined to a single bunk, the dysentary and other communicable diseases made the notion of escape nothing more than a distant, fuzzy dream. Taking their next breath was of greater immediacy and import. They were also lied to from the onset, to get them to cooperate. Once there, they were also made to believe that if they were compliant, they could work their way out of the camp. They truly believed they would be returning home at some point... or at minimum, that they would remain alive. From a distance, it's difficult to imagine the dynamic that was in force in the camps. Being there and listening to the guide and reading the posted plaques and signs and seeing the many items and rooms and buildings on display gave a far deeper sense of the powerlessness and hopelessness these people felt. The camps were also extremely isolated outside of the nearest towns, so that escapes were accomplished via miracle. Very few were ever successful. Escape and fighting back to 'take one with you' also requires at least a modicum of strength. Not much an unarmed and sickly, weak person can do against a robust, armed, and protected guard.

There's more I could say, but time is flying... at least in terms of the work I have in front of me that still needs to get done today.

~ Lizzy
Post Reply

Return to “News”