Geoffrey wrote: ↑Mon May 25, 2020 9:18 pm
...it must be wonderful to have faith, to throw intelligence, common sense, logic and the laws of physics to the wind.... i am almost tempted to get a lobotomy and join those fucking idiots
You really think it would be wonderful? I don't -- I love my brain, and to me, intelligence is bliss!
Incidentally, there are, actually, some very intelligent people in the world who also happen to have faith and who believe in god, etc.. It is thus an inaccurate generalisation to assume and assert that all believers are stupid. I used to be totally mystified by such individuals (intelligent believers), because it was unfathomable to me how someone with an otherwise keen brain could believe such things with the same certainty that they believed in logic and physics and the things explained by them. However, I eventually came to understand how it may be possible to explain how an intelligent person can believe in spirituality, faith, etc., through the writings of Kierkegaard and Wittgenstein.
The idea is that there are conceptual frameworks consisting of various tools and materials, through which we can explain and understand the things that exist, and also, there is more than one of those frameworks. So, we have to determine which framework to use in order to learn about and understand whatever it is that we are trying learn and understand. Different frameworks and the tools therein can only explain those things that fit into them -- that is, only those aspects of reality that are knowable and understandable through that framework and its tools/materials -- but it does not enable us to know and understand things/aspects of reality that require a different conceptual framework with different tools and materials that would enable us to know and understand it.
So, when it comes to understanding things like physics and the physical world, there is a certain framework that consists of various tools and materials and understandings -- logic and reason and mathematics -- that we can apply to those things, and by which we can learn about them and understand them. But, the tools and materials and understandings that we find in that particular framework will not work in different realms, such as in a spiritual realm. If a person perceives, or wants to perceive, something that exists in a spiritual realm, in order to know and understand it, they must use a conceptual framework and tools and materials that are applicable to that aspect of reality, and a framework that includes logic and reason is simply not the right one to use.
I suppose, by analogy, one can think about the conceptual framework and tools and materials that one uses to bake a cake, versus the ones used to build a house, or the ones used to fix a car. In each of these examples, what a person wishes to understand and accomplish are very different, and require very different kinds of tools and materials and understandings in order to be successful. One will not be able to figure out how to build a house, nor be able to build a house, from what they find in a bakery -- the tools and materials used for baking are simply not the right ones to use for carpentry. Nor will a person have any luck trying to figure out how to bake a cake, nor be able to bake one, by going to an auto mechanic's shop and trying to use the tools and materials found there. Each of these people must find the right framework -- the right tools and materials and understandings, etc. -- in order to be able to accomplish their respective tasks, otherwise, they will have to say "I simply cannot do/make/understand a cake with all these wrenches and bottles of motor oil...". Furthermore, one would not say that the framework, tools, materials, understandings... that are required to bake a cake are wrong or useless or meaningless or stupid, just because a carpenter cannot use them to build a house. Neither would one force a baker to use the tools of a mechanic to bake a cake, insisting that they are the only tools that can be used, for everything! Obviously, there are totally different tools, materials, etc., that people use for different things.
So, back to Kierkegaard and Wittgenstein, trying to get to know or understand a spiritual dimension, faith, religion., etc., by using the framework and tools and materials of logic, reason, mathematics, etc., will not work, because they're the wrong tools -- those tools are designed for the physical world, and thus the framework is wrong for the task and for understanding the spiritual objects in question. Therefore, one has to find and use a different framework and different tools, ones that will allow a person to learn about, know, understand, and explain things that cannot be known or understood or explained using the framework, tools, and materials, that one uses for the physical world.
Capiche?
